Find out what's popular at American Cheese in real-time and see activity, reviews and ratings!. Wines change seasonally and local beers change weekly! Stop by for a glass. American Cheese, Sayville: See 35 unbiased reviews of American Cheese, rated of 5 on TripAdvisor and ranked #9 of 58 restaurants in Sayville. How to Make Homemade American Cheese SMALL PLATES *available after 5pm Thursday - Saturday Winter Craft Beer &Wine Bar Photo of American Cheese - Sayville, NY, United States. An example of the Photo of American Cheese - Sayville, NY, United States. The Eatery. American Cheese.