Jun 17, A. The good news is that you can freeze cream cheese frosting, although it can take a bit of work to get the original texture back. Cream cheese. Oct 19, I made far too much cream cheese frosting for my carrot cake and Do you think the frosting would still be viable if I freeze, then defrost it in the. After everything is warmed cream the butter and cream cheese together, add in the vanilla and last add in the powdered sugar. If you want your frosting sweeter add more powdered sugar. Freeze your frosting before or after frosting the cake. To freeze separately place into a plastic freezer bag and freeze flat. Can you freeze a cupcake with cream cheese frosting Yes, I have frozen leftover cream cheese frosting for over 2 months.. let it You can also pass the icing through a sieve to get rid of the lumps. Aug 10, Cream cheese frosting is not likely to freeze well: it becomes watery and crumbly. "Be sure to defrost the frosting completely before you re-whip it," says Chef Melanie, "and adjust the texture with just a little milk if needed". Jun 17, A. The good news is that you can freeze cream cheese frosting, although it can take a bit of work to get the original texture back. Cream cheese.