I got this recipe off a box of Muellers brand elbow macaroni. It is a little time consuming but well worth the effort. It is my favorite macaroni and cheese recipe. shredded American or Cheddar cheese, divided; 8 oz ( grm). Mueller's Elbows (about 2 cups), cooked 5 minutes and drained. Preparation. In medium. MUELLER'S BAKED MACARONI AND CHEESE. Submitted by joannba Updated: September 24, 0/4 fork user rating. reviews (0). 0%. make it again.